Skip to Content

My Experience Casting for Master Chef US

Auditioning for a reality television series is not something I had ever dreamed of or planned on doing. But last year, I found myself, among other hundreds of contestants, waiting in line at Hilton Hotel in downtown Minneapolis for a casting call of Fox’s cooking competition series Master Chef US. 

I found out only a week before, after a friend of mine posted it on my Facebook page encouraging me to participate.

dacquoise hazelnuts cake with white chocolate mousse

I was very reserved at the beginning, because I never liked these kind of shows.

Especially after watching Master Chef Romania (the country I moved from to the US many years ago), I told everyone that there is no way in hell I would ever audition or expose myself on any of these shows, as I would never be able to put up with the verbal abuse and humiliation happening to the contestants…

I was not into watching the Master Chef of US either, so I was not sure if the verbal abuse happens there also.  

On the back of my mind, though, I was curious to see if I would even be able to make it through the first casting, so I started to watch the last season and get familiar with the requirements.

During the process, I fantasized about the plate I would present and think about the logistics for that day.

I do not know about you, but I am always worried about my image out there.

Besides the fact that I never liked the attention in public, I also never thought I would look good on TV or have the right personality for a show like that.

Also, I was and am still convinced that my mind would never be able to work that fast to put together a dish in 3 minutes after opening a box full of surprise ingredients that have no connection with each other. 

When I entertain, I like to take my time, think about the menu, plan in advance.

When I bake a cake, I take a lot of time to think about how the cake would look like, if the flavors would go well together, if the decorations would fit the occasion, etc…

However, even if I was trying to convince myself that there are so many reasons why I shouldn’t go,  I kind of needed validation from someone who doesn’t know me…

You know how all your family and friends tell you how great you are as a cook or a baker,  but you think that they only want to be nice to you?

This is me….not trusting myself enough, so for that matter, I decided to challenge myself, as usual, and go for the Master Chef casting and get that stupid feedback I needed so much.

So, I pre-registered, not yet convinced that I will even make it there on Saturday.

I did not want to stress myself and be disappointed, so I told everyone that if my dish comes outright, I will go; if I am not satisfied with it, I will not.

However, on Tuesday before the casting, a producer from Los Angeles called me to make sure that I will be there on Saturday.

She was able to take a look at my blog, liked it very much and encouraged me to go.

I told her that I never applied for any show before; I am not confident that I could even pass the first casting, and that I am thinking not to go.

She said that I should try, as it seems my blog was very interesting for them.

They liked the fact that I can cook many things, I can also bake, and that my food looks outstanding in terms of plating.

The audition would start at 10 am, but she scheduled me between 12-2 pm. She also explained to me the process a little bit.

She said that we will be invited in groups of 10-15 people and that 4 tasters will taste our food.

We would have only 3 minutes to plate the food before that.The dish was to be planned and prepared ahead of time.

We could make anything we wanted, but it had to be served as is. They would not provide us with any electrical outlets to warm or finish our dishes.

Full of confidence, I started to really plan on what to bring to the audition.

I have to say that because of so many years of experience in the kitchen, I feel like I am a better cook than a baker.

However, as I graduated two years ago from pastry school training back in Romania, I decided to make a cake.  A fancy one, where I can show many techniques.

My thought was that if I would make a dish, it will be challenging to keep a decent temperature on it for many hours, and the texture would change in time.

Also, because it was summer and I had no idea how long we will be there, I was worried about the safety of eating food that was kept warm for so long.

I chose this cake,  a dacquoise hazelnuts cake with white chocolate mousse and a strawberry and pistachios insertion in the middle, because the cake was supposed to be frozen overnight and decorated the same day with the audition.

Waiting for many hours in line, would give the cake the right consistency and also would be safe for eating.

 I chose the recipe from Ana Consulea’s repertoire, a famous Romanian pastry chef I met last year while on vacation in Bucharest. I had the honor to met her and work in her kitchen for 3 days, where I learned lots of new things.

I made the cake once and noticed few issues with it.  Here is the first version of it.

dacquoise hazelnuts cake with white chocolate mousse

The top of the cake is not very smooth, but not bad overall.

slice of dacquoise hazelnuts cake with white chocolate mousse

The layers inside the cake looked like this:

Slice of white chocolate cake with berries

The only problem was that the cake was melting, and the glaze on top was runny, a sign that it needed more gelatin.

I was nervous about getting to the audition with a cake that would not hold together, so I contacted Ana Consulea and asked her about the recipe.

She was extremely helpful and gave me lots of tips on how to succeed with it.

Friday morning, a day before the audition, I made another cake, thinking that it will be the one that I will take with me the next day.

As I said before, the white chocolate glaze on the first cake was a little runny, so I decided to put more gelatin sheets in the mixture this time. 

BIG MISTAKE! The glaze came out like glue, was thick and impossible to spread on the cake! BUMMER!

White chocolate cake with berries

The surface is bumpy and thick and not appetizing at all, even though I tried to decorate it nicely. uggghhhh!

Almost crying,  I told my husband that I need white chocolate, as I have to bake another cake, now that I ruined the one I was working on…at 8 pm that night, my husband got in the car (he was not very happy, let me tell you that!) and went to the grocery store to pick up more ingredients.

So, I started to basically work on my third cake! This time, I was decided, one more mistake and I am not going.

I was convinced that if I get there, the cake has to look impeccable, the taste should be amazing, the textures should be right, and overall, the cake should be the perfect cake ever!

I baked that night, put the cake together, and shoved it in the freezer until Saturday morning, when I was supposed to glaze and decorate it before the audition.

The next morning went by without any major events, so I left the house with this one:

dacquoise hazelnuts cake with white chocolate mousse

I even had time to make little gum paste flower decorations and a transparent glaze for the fresh fruit. I was finally delighted with the results!

I tried to dress up for the occasion, as they said: do not wear any logos, t-shirts with inscriptions, jeans or anything like that.

The first impression counts a lot, so dress like you would go for an interview.

I never go out of my house in sweat pants anyway, so I wore a nice blouse, a skirt down to my knees, and a pair of cute flats.

I wanted to be comfortable and presentable at the same time. I had no idea if we will have a place to sit there, if it will be inside or outside and how long we will have to wait in line.

We got to Hilton Hotel in Minneapolis on time, and I hand them the application with a million questions about myself that I had to complete before the audition.

I received a sheet with my name on it, the dish’s name to attach to our application, and a number. Mine was #162.

Master Chef US- banner

I was guided to a waiting room with chairs where many people were waiting—lots of people wearing jeans, t-shirts, and shorts.

So much for following the rules, huh? Anyway, I only had to wait for about an hour until I could get inside the tasting room.

My experience casting for Master Chef US- Auditioning for a reality television series
Me waiting in line holding the cake

Groups of 10-15 were brought into the room at a time. I looked around and saw that in my group, I was the only one with a dessert.

My husband told me, though, that outside was many people who brought cupcakes and other sweetbreads, so I was not the only one.

I noticed that many people in the room had a lot of pasta dishes and fried food. I did not see any salads or fresh vegetables, and I did not notice any colorful plates.

We had 3 minutes to plate the food. I was nervous about slicing my cake…you know how the first piece usually comes out really hard, and doesn’t have the best look?

So, I said a prayer and started to slice the cake. I took the piece out, and it looked PERFECT, so I put it on the plate and quickly decorated it.

After the 3 minutes were up, somebody came and took a picture of each of us with the application and the plate we brought.

A taster came around and questioned each dish. When he got in front of me, he asked me to describe the dish.

He said that the plate looks gorgeous and the presentation is very nice. Then he tasted the cake and said that it was delicious.

He asked about the middle of the cake, and I put pistachios only on top of the cake, or there are pistachios somewhere else.

I told him that the insertion of the cake has pistachios that were added to the strawberries for texture and crunchiness.

He was very pleased and overall he told me that my dish is very tasty and beautiful.

He also looked at the entire cake and said that it looked really nice. The producers also walked around the room and told me that the cake looked gorgeous.

After that, an interviewer(producer) came and quickly tried to find out a little bit more about me.

“Did you ever attend a culinary school? Did you ever work as a cook or a baker in a professional kitchen? Are you married? Do you have any children? How old are they? How long have you been in this country? Where are you from? What hobbies do you have? “

After all these questions, they selected a few people from the group to interview further, and the rest of us were free to go home.

I was not selected among the ones who went further. Although my cake looked perfect and the taster liked it very much, I was not selected.

Right next to me, though, was this young guy, who wore a pink suit and a black T-shirt with a white skull on it.

He came with a huge Davanni’s pizza box where he had a Cheese curds pizza with some fresh basil on it.

Somebody even asked him if he really made the pizza or just bought it. He had Davanni’s name crossed from the box with a black sharpie, and his name was written on it instead. He actually made it to the next round of interviews with his cheese curds pizza.

One observation, though…Very few people from my group made it to the next level, and most of them were much younger than me, so I am wondering…

If the show is really about the best home cooks in America, wouldn’t you think that many of the competitors should be older people with many years of experience? 

People, who have years of studying cookbooks, perfecting family recipes, or traveling the world to try new cuisines? You look at past seasons of the show, and you really see photogenic 20-30 somethings, many of them with media experience and aspirations to become TV stars.

Maybe I am wrong, but even the older ones who made it to the show were eliminated in the first episodes, making you wonder.

It seemed that most of the people I saw that day getting a “golden ticket” for further interviews were on the younger side.

Were these people really “the best home cooks in America,” or were they just the best at getting on television, with their young age and appearance?

I took some time to think about if I want to write this post or not. I did not want to come as a “crying loser” or be unfair about showing that so many people are watching.

However, it seems to me that not only this show, but most of the shows on TV are all about younger people.

I cannot say that I have any insight into what the casting people are looking for in a contestant and how the “Top 100” people out of thousands who show up at casting calls are chosen.

As I said before, I might not have the look or the personality they are looking for, and I am totally fine with it!

In truth, I never liked the drama in these shows, and I always said that I would hate to go through the grueling experience of being in a reality show anyway and having people around the world commenting and criticizing me based on what they see, and not on what actually happens while the show is filmed.

However,  I do still question the honesty of the show and what is all about.

One thing I know is that before leaving the house that day, I prayed and ask God to help me go through the experience in an honorable way. My plate was gorgeous, and lots of people were very impressed with how the cake looked like. I got lots of compliments on my way in and out of that place.

Then, I gained a lot of experience making this recipe that was not very easy for a beginner baker as myself. 

All my 3 cakes went downstairs in the Community area of the building we live, and lots of people had a piece of cake during that week while practicing.

None of them was unhappy with it, so from that perspective, I got again the confidence that whatever I am doing, I am doing it well.

 I am proud of myself for having the guts to apply to the show and go through the experience.

And finally, I will always be my husband and my daughter’s Master Chef, as they call me, and that is all that matters! 🙂

Note to the readers: The event happened at the end of August 2015

Note: “We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to and affiliated sites.”

Kelly Cuci

Monday 30th of September 2019

Hi Gabriela Your cake was beautiful. Props to you that you took that chance. I'm auditioning for the 2020 season. Any pointers you could share. Thanks Kelly

The Bossy Kitchen

Monday 30th of September 2019

Thank you, Kelly. I don't have a lot of tips to give you. They are looking for certain personalities, that would make the show more interesting. I guess I was too boring for their taste. :-) Go there, do your best and you will be fine. It is a fun experience. If you go there with no expectations, other than doing well, you will not have any disappointments. Good Luck!


Friday 21st of September 2018

Hello, I just wanted to say, I too auditioned for master chef in august of 2015 in Austin TX, I made my homemade spaghettie and meatball sauce with portuguise linguica, they loved it but I didnt get in, at first i did cry, but it felt great to step (finally) outside of my comfort zone. I love to cook and it is satisfying to see my son and husband really enjoy the food that I cook. I am super critical of myself and sometimes it makes me cook my best. Cooking really is my passion, I enjoyed reading your post!


Friday 14th of September 2018

Gabriela, your cake is beautiful! I went to the 2018 Minneapolis audition and I could tell that they were testing for personality. I think they want to see that you can cook, and that you can talk about your cooking, but ultimately they are selecting candidates who will have dynamic responses to events in the competition. They do, after all, have to generate hours and hours of content, and you are the star. I don't think it has so much to do with age. But it definitely does not come down to if you had the best food in the room.

The Bossy Kitchen

Sunday 16th of September 2018

Hi Aleks, For sure I do not have the personality for a TV show, so maybe that was the reason, I don't know. I hope you did well, as I saw your website and it looks great. Maybe we should get together and chat more.

Quinisha Story

Wednesday 29th of August 2018

Thank you for sharing your story Gabriela, I always wondered what they actually looked for in terms of participants for the show. While I’m a little bit nervous I’m looking forward to the opportunity. I just want to know since they don’t have a place to warm your food or hold it I’m wondering can you just come with the dishes already prepared to serve vs. preparing it there???


Sunday 9th of September 2018

That would like for you to plate there but I saw no rule against having it preplated.

The Bossy Kitchen

Wednesday 29th of August 2018

Hi, I would ask that question directly to them if you can, as I am not sure if the rules are the same since I participated. However, when I went to the event, they told us that the food should be already prepared. They do not provide a kitchen or a place to cook/warm up food.The organizers gave us exactly 3 minutes to plate what we brought. I chose a cake because I was not sure how long I will have to wait in line, how hot is going to be there or anything else related to the event. Most people brought the food in insulated bags to keep it cold or hot. Keep in mind again that it is not only about the food, they take in consideration a lot of other things. Dress comfortable, be yourself, bring a dish that you love making and have fun with it. Also, make sure you have a plate for the food and all the necessary tools for plating the dish(spoons, forks, a knife, a towel or whatever you might need). Good luck!


Thursday 2nd of August 2018

Hi Gabriela, I am from New Zealand, a 30 year old female, a trained working chef and patissiere in my earier twenties and huge fan of masterchef australia, and came across your post during a search... I have always been completely baffled by the difference in standards between masterchef australia and masterchef US which you auditioned for (and other versions), I'm sure others have replied to your post, but I have also come across comments from production members which have confirmed that the difference is that versions other than australia are casting for a reality show rather than a cooking competition. I really really appreciate your post as I have always wondered about the US process. I realise others may have replied re: this (I couldn't see the date of your post), but just incase, I wanted to encourage you to try again if you ever get similar opportunities. Particularly I noticed that you wrote a fair amount about dress / presentation standards. Personality and character is the largest factor that works in your favour (see your story about the person with the pizza box) and producers / preliminary judges look for this. Therefore they really don't want you to dress in any way other than you usually present yourself - to dress up in smart clothes won't help. The reason they are asking you not to wear jeans, shirts with logos isn't to do with casual vs. smart dress standards, (you should present yourself in your typical manner that you are comfortable in). The reason they reinforce this is because they can't use any footage / images of you if you are wearing clothes on camera that promote any kind of branding / company. Its a legal thing. (and just as pizza box man, this likely won't stop you getting a call back if they like you, but they really don't want everyone showing up in clothes that they can't use on film, which is a television problem and therefore something a producer will always tell you). I can really see you do have a lot of talent, a voice, and capability to kick ass on a show like this. And I would love to see someone just like you on a show like this US version of materchef, as it would make it watchable! I really encourage you to try again, and bring all of your every day personality (conversationally, confidence and presentation-wise) with you! Thanks so much for you post anyway - you've done something most people wouldn't do and I'll remember this post and appreciate your account of your experience :) Nga mihi mahana

The Bossy Kitchen

Thursday 2nd of August 2018

Hi Kathy, Thank you so much for your kind words and encouragements! You are so sweet! I am not interested to participate again, but it was an interesting experience that I wanted to share with my readers. The article is from 2016, a little bit old.I personally enjoy shows like "The British Baking show", the atmosphere is a little bit less intense. I never watched Master Chef Australia, but I would be curious to see it. I watched the one from Canada and that one was very different compared with the US version. I hope you get the chance to compete in your country. If you do, let me know how the experience was for you. And thanks again for visiting my blog!